We've often been led to believe that brown is healthier than white—whether it's in bread, rice, or sugar. But when it comes to sugar, is brown sugar really better than white sugar? This blog, drawing on the latest scientific research, explores whether switching to brown sugar offers any health benefits, especially for those managing conditions like diabetes.
White sugar undergoes a refining process that removes molasses, which is a byproduct of sugarcane extraction. Brown sugar, on the other hand, either retains some of this molasses or is made by blending white sugar with molasses, giving it its distinct brown color and slightly different texture.
Brown sugar contains trace amounts of minerals like calcium, potassium, magnesium, and iron due to the molasses. However, the amounts are so small that they don't make a significant nutritional difference. For example, a tablespoon of brown sugar contains less than 1% of your daily recommended intake of these minerals. White sugar lacks these minerals entirely.
Brown sugar contains slightly fewer calories than white sugar, but the difference is minimal. A teaspoon of brown sugar provides about 17 calories, while white sugar provides about 16 calories. The slight difference is not enough to consider one healthier than the other in terms of caloric intake.
Sugar consumption, whether white or brown, is closely linked to an increased risk of obesity, type 2 diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. Both types of sugar have a high glycemic index (GI), meaning they raise blood sugar levels quickly. This can pose risks for people with diabetes or those prone to insulin resistance.
As an experienced dietitian with international certification in diabetes education, it's essential to emphasize that neither brown nor white sugar is significantly better in managing blood glucose levels. According to a study published in the Journal of Nutrition & Metabolism (2020), the effects of both sugars on blood glucose levels are nearly identical. Thus, switching to brown sugar does not offer substantial metabolic benefits.
While the health impacts are nearly identical, the differences in taste and texture are worth noting:
Regardless of which type of sugar you prefer, moderation is key. The World Health Organization recommends that added sugars (both white and brown) should make up no more than 5–10% of your daily calorie intake to reduce the risk of chronic diseases. For someone consuming 2,000 calories a day, this means limiting sugar intake to about 25 grams, or 6 teaspoons.
When it comes to health, there is no significant advantage to choosing brown sugar over white sugar. Both should be consumed in moderation, as excess intake of either type can contribute to serious health issues like diabetes and heart disease. While brown sugar offers a more complex flavor profile in certain recipes, it doesn’t provide a meaningful nutritional edge. If you're looking to make healthier dietary choices, focus on reducing your overall sugar intake, regardless of its color.
By making mindful, science-based dietary decisions, you can better manage your health, particularly if you are at risk of or managing diabetes.
Sources: